Jennifer Scott Dunedin Nurse Disciplined for protecting children from Forced Sterilization

Written by Pamela Taylor 5th September 2023

Jennifer Scott a Dunedin Nurse that has the ability to practice nursing that meets the needs of clients cared for using logical thinking and accurate nursing skills, as she has been advocating for New Zealand Children to be Respected and Protected as per New Zealand's obligations under the UNCROC, Geneva Protocol I, Geneva Protocol II, and Rome Statutes.

Whereas Jennifer believes that a child is any person who has not reached the age of 18 years. She is advocating for New Zealand children to be protected from sexual grooming, rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced chemical sterilization, enforced surgical castration, sexual violence and sexual exploitation. Jennifer believes that all New Zealand children should be protected from all forms of sexual exploitation and sexual abuse, and that they should not be subjected to torture or any other cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment or medical experimentation.

Whereas Nursing Council of New Zealand senior legal adviser Clare Prendergast has confirmed Jennifer Scott had her Practising Certificate suspended as advocating for New Zealand Children to be Respected and Protected as per New Zealand's obligations under the UNCROC, Geneva Protocol I, Geneva Protocol II, and Rome Statutes is currently in conflict with Nursing Council of New Zealand Policies and Procedures. That means she was unable to practise nursing at present.

Whereas Jennifer is the author of New Zealand and Gender Dysphoria in Youth the only research on Gender Dysphoria in Youth currently available in New Zealand. Being a Registered Nurse with a Bachelor of Nursing, PDRP Level 3 (Mental Health) a Certificate in Health Sciences (Mental Health) a Certificate in Herbal Medicines and researched Gender Dysphoria she has become New Zealand's leading expert in this field.

Whereas according to Jennifer, Gender Dysphoria (GD) in children, is also known as gender identity disorder or gender incongruence of childhood, refers to discomfort or distress that is caused by a discrepancy between a person’s gender identity (how they see themselves regarding their gender) and that person’s sex at birth and the associated gender role, and/or primary and secondary sex characteristics.

Whereas according to Jennifer, Humans are born either Male XY or Female XX with (0.018% to 1.7%) of the population born intersex. Any chromosomal abnormalities usually correspond to genetic features and is not an indication of someone being transgender and those born intersex have disorders of sexual development (Sax L, 2002).

Whereas according to Jennifer, Puberty Blockers have been advertised on the MINISTRY of HEALTH website as a treatment option for children and adolescents who have Gender Dysphoria or their ‘gender identity’ is of the opposite sex. There is also additional information and links to resources about cross sex hormones and genital surgery provided on the website.

Whereas according to Jennifer, Puberty Blockers cause superfluous injury and unnecessary suffering to children and are intended to cause pain and long-term effects beyond that which is a natural incident of being injured or disabled. The negative effects that Puberty Blocker drugs have on a developing child are not reversible. Puberty Blockers effect the development of sex organs and can cause infertility. Cross-sex hormones are associated with cardiovascular complications, including a fourfold increased risk of heart attacks in biological females, and a threefold increase in the incidence of venous thromboembolism in biological males. Suddenly stopping hormones of any kind—in particular testosterone—can result in withdrawal symptoms. Symptoms can be physical, including, fatigue, loss of appetite, insomnia, muscle and joint pain, and hot flushes, and also psychological, including feelings of depression, mood swings, and suicidal thoughts (Malone, 2020). Side effects of hormone therapy are blood clots, gallstones, weight gain, acne, hair loss, sleep apnoea and, eventually, infertility. The ovaries of women given testosterone correspond to those found in PCOS, which itself is associated with increased ovarian cancer risk and metabolic abnormalities and venous thromboembolism risk is elevated fivefold in males taking estrogen (Laidlaw et al, 2019).

Whereas according to Jennifer, Puberty Blockers cause permeant Brain Damage. A global IQ decrease (WISC-III) was reported in a longitudinal follow-up of girls with central precocious puberty (Schuerger and Witt, 1989, quoted in Schneider et al., 2017, p5) treated with GnRHa. Finally, a third study correlated verbal skill impairment to pubertal suppression in a GD group (Costa et al., 2015 quoted in Schneider et al., 2017, p5). This study goes on to state that white matter fractional anisotropy did not increase, compared to normal male puberty effects on the brain and further longitudinal studies are needed in order to confirm findings and support the hypothesis on the impact of sex hormones on cognition and brain maturity during developmental stages (Schneider et al, 2017). The findings of (Wojniusz et al. 2016, cited in Hayes, 2017) can be compared with those of a 2001 study in which 25 children treated for early puberty with triptorelin acetate were tested with the short form Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (Mul et al., 2001, cited in Hayes, 2017). In this longitudinal study, children took the IQ test before treatment and again after 2 years of treatment. It was found that their IQ dropped 7 points from 100 to 93. With 25 treated participants, this 7 point drop was significant (p = 0.002). In both studies the difference in the performance element of the test was greater than in the verbal element. The similarities between the findings of these two studies strengthens their reliability and increases the possibility that GnRHa treatment may have an adverse impact on cognitive functioning in children. This makes it yet more important for further research to be carried out into the effects GnRHas may have on cognitive performance in children (Hayes, 2017).

In Female to Male patients, the following physical changes are expected to occur: deepened voice, clitoral enlargement (variable), growth in facial and body hair, cessation of menses, atrophy of breast tissue, and decreased percentage of body fat compared to muscle mass.

In Male to Female patients, the following physical changes are expected to occur: breast growth (variable), decreased erectile function, decreased testicular size, and increased percentage of body fat compared to muscle mass. Most physical changes, whether feminizing or masculinizing, occur over the course of two years. The amount of physical change and the exact timeline of effects can be highly variable (Coleman, et al, 2012, p. 36).

The effects of Oestrogen:

Breast growth: Reversibility: Not possible

Decreased testicular volume: Reversibility: Unknown

Decreased sperm production: Reversibility: Unknown

(Oliphant, et al, 2018, p. 34)

The effects of Testosterone:

Facial body/hair growth: Reversibility: Unlikely

Scalp hair loss: Reversibility: Unlikely

Clitoral enlargement: Reversibility: Unlikely

Vaginal atrophy: Reversibility: Unlikely

Deepening of voice: Reversibility: Not possible

(Oliphant, et al, 2018, p. 36)

Whereas according to Jennifer, Genital Surgery also cause superfluous injury and unnecessary suffering to children and are intended to cause pain and long-term effects beyond that which is a natural incident of being injured or disabled. The negative effects that Puberty Blocker drugs have on a developing child are not reversible.

A natal female who has a double mastectomy cannot reverse the procedure, while a natal male who takes estrogen in order to grow breasts will have them for the rest of their life. Both a ‘phalloplasty’ – the creation of a penis for a natal female – and a ‘vaginoplasty’ – the opposite procedure for a natal male – are hard to reverse for obvious reasons ’ (Young, 2019, p.15). Gender-affirming surgeries can cause urethral stricture, neo-vaginal stenosis and prolapse, and long-term post-mastectomy pain (D’Angelo, 2020).

Whereas according to Jennifer, with all of the negative, adverse, irreversible and unknown side effects listed above and more listed from New Zealand and Gender Dysphoria in Youth and from International studies, research and within the MINISTRY OFHEALTH own documents on gender affirming healthcare it is misleading and inappropriate for the statement to be made that they are “safe and fully reversible”. Puberty Blockers are exposing vulnerable children to unacceptable risks. Evidence of the Physical and Psychological effects of Puberty Blockers and Genital Surgery shows that they are NOT safe and are NOT fully reversible. All New Zealand children have the Right to be protected from rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced biological and chemical sterilization, surgical sterilization and sexual violence. The GOVERNMENT, the MEDIA, the MINISTRY OF HEALTH and the MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, the Politicians, Journalists, Doctors, Nurses and Teachers should NOT use lawful compulsion, they should NOT use their position of authority to influence, or force (compel), children to use dangerous and not reversible Puberty Blockers and get Genital Surgery to sterilize and mutilate themselves.

Whereas the GOVERNMENT, the MEDIA, the MINISTRY OF HEALTH and the MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, the Politicians, Journalists, Doctors, Nurses and Teachers are currently using booby traps that target vulnerable children. These booby traps are Rainbow Flags, Drag Queen Story Time, Porn in School Libraries, Rainbow Images associated with children's toys or other portable objects, or products specially designed for feeding, health, hygiene, clothing or education of children. Every year, NEW ZEALAND companies and ratepayer funded organisations spend thousands of dollars to get a Rainbow Tick. These include Auckland Council, which has paid $21,000 since 2016 to Rainbow Tick for its certification and assessment via focus groups. Massey University was certified in 2016 the university has paid $20,700 to Rainbow Tick. These organisations then display Rainbow Images as propaganda to attract vulnerable children and young adults towards Gender Dysphoria, Sexual Experimentation, Puberty Blockers and getting Genital Surgery to sterilize and mutilate themselves. Huge amounts of NEW ZEALAND GOVERNMENT money currently are being used to for propaganda targeting vulnerable children in order to trick, deceive, lie, use medical fraud, and booby traps of colorful balloons, party images, cartoons, Drag Queens, flags, clothing, and toys promote Gender Dysphoria, Sexual Experimentation, Puberty Blockers and getting Genital Surgery. They are sexually grooming the children, by telling them that they should have PRIDE once they have sterilized themselves through Puberty Blockers and Genital Surgery.

Whereas Jennifer is advocating for Woman and Children to be the object of special respect and to be protected in particular against rape, enforced prostitution, and any other form of indecent assault or gender-based violence. She is campaigning for biological Men to use Male bathrooms and for biological Woman and young children to use Female or Family bathrooms to protect Woman and Children from indecent assault and gender-based violence. For New Zealand to fulfill its obligations under the Geneva Convention IV art 85 which states "the provision of separate sleeping quarters and sanitary conveniences shall be obligatory" and Geneva Protocol I art 75 "woman... shall be held in quarters separated from men's quarters." For her comments that biological Men should NOT be in the Female changing rooms the previous Dunedin Mayor said her views were repulsive and transphobic.